Arizona band sues Apple, Chris Daughtry

By Whitney Willis · October 9, 2008 · Print This Article

LAKE HAVASU CITY — The lead singer of a local band is suing Apple and American Idol finalist Chris Daughtry and for copyright infringement over the song, “Feels Like Tonight.”

Randy Mazick, lead singer of The Asphalt, alleges Daughtry’s song “Feels Like Tonight” sounds like “Tonight,” which his band recorded a year earlier than Daughtry.

Daughtry was a contestant on the fifth season of American Idol, where he became a finalist and finished in fourth place. Record sales indicate he is the fourth most successful contestant in the show’s history. Daughtry’s first album, “Daughtry,” was released in 2006 and was the best selling album of 2007.

The Asphalt is a four-man band out of Lake Havasu City about four hours northwest of Phoenix. Mazick claims that songwriters Lukasz Gottwald, Martin Karl Sandberg and Sheppard Solomon’s song, “achieved worldwide success and notoriety since its release in November 2006,” according to the complaint.

The complaint also says the song’s hook is a copy of the copyrighted song “Tonight,” first publicly performed by Mazick’s band in 2005 and later performed throughout the Southwest.

The complaint was filed Sept. 17 and called for a jury trial. It states Mazick is “entitled to damages and to Defendant’s profits in amounts to be proven at trial, which are not currently ascertainable.”

Linda Schroeder, a court reporter for the U.S. District Court, said that the case could take up to three years to reach trial. In the meantime, the court could choose to take many actions, such as taking depositions of those involved, subpoenaing evidence, and getting sworn testimony.

Daughtry has yet to choose an attorney.

“A summons has been issued for each of the named defendants, and once they’re served, I’m sure an attorney will enter an appearance for them,” Schroeder said.

Jason Marino, guitarist and vocalist of The Asphalt, said in an e-mail that the band declined comment on the case.

Ray Harris, The Asphalt’s Phoenix attorney, said he could not comment on a case that is in litigation.

For more information on The Asphalt and to hear their song “Tonight,” visit www.myspace.com/theasphalt.

= = =

>>Email the editor at aklaw@zoniereport.com.


Comments

3 Responses to “Arizona band sues Apple, Chris Daughtry”

  1. Nicole on October 10th, 2008 7:01 am

    All Asphalt wants is daughtrys money. If Asphalt saying the defendents profits doesnt tell you that all he wants is money, you need to look closer. I listened to both of the songs and they sound nothing alike. The only words that are the same are Feels Like Tonight, but its not even the same melody.

  2. Natalia on October 24th, 2008 7:33 am

    Chris Daughtry will lose this suit because Clive Davis got the boot and won’t be able to help him any more. Daughtry hasn’t done anything since he is without Davis to bribe the radio stations to play that garbage. The only thing he can get now is an appearance on CSI. It’s not the first time that Daughtry lied about a song either but anyone that tried to say anything got a cease and desist from Freemantle. http://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/archives/american_idol_5/2006_Mar_27_chris_walk_line_controversy

  3. Pages tagged "daughtry" on October 25th, 2008 3:33 am

    [...] bookmarks tagged daughtrynetwork storage devices arizona band sues apple, chris daughtry saved by 24 others     PerfectTimeBomb bookmarked on 10/25/08 | [...]

Got something to say?